Monday, November 16, 2020

Topaze

The 2020 Barrymore Trilogy Blogathon is an event honoring the prolific Barrymore family of actors, especially the siblings John, Ethel and Lionel Barrymore, hosted by In the Good Old Days of Classic Hollywood. For a complete list of participating bloggers, visit the link at the host site.

Topaze

YouTube viewing 

The Barrymore clan of thespians dominated the American entertainment field more than any other family in the 20th century. The modern representative, Drew, is very much active; she currently has a daytime talk show on TV.

The clan goes back at least as far as the 19th century and possibly further than that—this article gives you an overview—but classic movie fans are perhaps most familiar with the triumvirate of siblings John, Ethel and Lionel. I’ve talked about Ethel before; for this year’s blogathon I’ll discuss John.

His father Maurice was a Broadway actor and a middleweight boxer, and was the first in the family to assume the stage name Barrymore (he was born Herbert Blythe), after English actor William Barrymore. John’s mother was also an actor, Georgiana Drew; the Drew name has also been handed down the generations. John was the youngest of their three children, after Lionel and Ethel.

They called him “The Great Profile”—he made a movie by that name too—though I’ve looked and looked and I can’t see what was so special about his profile. Aquiline nose, thin lips, sturdy chin, I see all of that, but you could say that about lots of other men. I guess it was a cultural thing no one cares about anymore.

I don’t have anything against him. He was fine in the other films I’ve seen him in, but I never thought of him as being over and above other actors. I don’t think he’s better than, say, Spencer Tracy, for instance. In fact, I prefer Lionel—but maybe I haven’t seen enough of John’s films.

Not only has John played himself in movies, so have others: WC Fields, Fredric March (a disguised version), Errol Flynn, and Christopher Plummer, among others, so obviously there was something to his legacy that inspired familiarity, kinda like when someone imitates Bogart or Cagney or Brando.

John was a stage actor for years before entering film, where much of his reputation was built. Unfortunately I can’t see him in this context; perhaps if I could, I’d appreciate him more. As a silent film actor, he also excelled; his celluloid portrayals of Hamlet, Jekyll & Hyde and Richard III were probably the definitive versions for those who never saw him on a stage.

When sound came to the movies, John signed with Warner Bros. at first, then MGM, plus he made some films at RKO during this time. It was at RKO that he made today’s subject, Topaze, produced by David O. Selznick, an adaptation of a play.

In France (though, of course, the principal actors don’t bother with accents), a meek schoolteacher is too good at his job for the likes of the aristocratic mother of a brat, which leads to his dismissal—until he’s snatched up by the father to help promote his sparkling water, unaware that it’s a subpar product.

John reminded me of Lionel in his portrayal of Topaze: his tone of voice, some of his mannerisms, were reminiscent of Lionel in Grand Hotel, made a year earlier. I imagine the two of them were probably competitive, each trying to outdo the other.

I was more interested in the subplot about the baroness who got Topaze fired because he wouldn’t give her brat a passing grade. Later in the movie they meet under different circumstances and Topaze makes a feeble attempt to disguise himself. She doesn’t recognize him, which I didn’t buy.

Topaze had some funny moments, but it didn’t have as much of a satirical bite as other, later films like It Should Happen to You (a guileless innocent caught up in the cynical world of advertising) or Being There (a guileless innocent used as a pawn by others but remains uniquely himself). It was a nice idea, but ultimately not that interesting.

Myrna Loy is wasted in this movie as the mistress of the sparkling water baron. Anybody could’ve played her role.

———————

Previously:

Portrait of Jennie

2 comments:

  1. I haven't seen Topaze yet, but I am curious about the play and its adaption. Back in 1930, Frank Morgan played the role on Broadway. It is interesting to compare the performances of Morgan to those of Barrymore.

    If you haven't seen them, I can recommend a double bill of Barrymore features with Twentieth Century and Counsellor-at-Law.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I could easily see Frank Morgan as Topaze.

    I have seen TWENTIETH CENTURY; very good movie. Might have seen COUNSELOR AT LAW; don’t recall.

    ReplyDelete